An Analog Boat in a Digital World
When I sat down to write this issue’s editor’s page, my newly updated version of Microsoft Word opened with a small window asking me, “What would you like Copilot to draft.” Copilot is Word’s artificial intelligence (AI) companion. You give it parameters, and it spits out a composition for you, no thinking required. I’ve never used it—or any AI—to do my writing for me. I don’t intend to, either, but when Copilot made me that offer, I was curious to see what it could do. I typed, “Draft a 500-word essay on the significance of the schooner BRILLIANT to sail training.”
Within about five seconds, I was reading 500 words of somewhat accurate, coldly composed, grammatically perfect, sleep-inducing tripe about the schooner BRILLIANT. It had no personality and was loaded with repetitive triple-object series such as “…skills, values, and inspiration; navigate, handle sails, and maintain the vessel; resilience, environmental awareness, and the value of skill….” It had no quotations nor personal experiences to back up those assertions of values. It had no soul.
As an antidote, I thought back to one still morning sometime in the late 1980s when I awoke aboard a classic English cutter in the harbor in Marion, Massachusetts. I was on a boat delivery, and we’d moored the night before next to BRILLIANT. I was up early, sipping coffee on deck, and was awed both by the schooner’s seemingly perfect condition and the swarm of crewmembers tending to her: wiping down the brightwork with chamois cloths, polishing brass and bronze. It would be several years before I got to know BRILLIANT and a succession of her legendary captains, and to learn of the ongoing maintenance philosophy that has kept her in top condition. As her current captain, Sarah Armour, notes in her article beginning on page 18, BRILLIANT is largely original and has aged so well because she has been maintained consistently and impeccably, rather than been rebuilt. Still, large projects, Sarah notes, “come along now and then.”
Last winter saw a large project on BRILLIANT. She was hauled into the shed at Rockport Marine in Maine and a number of long-monitored frames and floor timers were repaired or replaced; she was repowered, and the ballast keel bolts were inspected and replaced along with a number of deadwood bolts. The entire project, which Sarah walks us through in her article, was completed in time for BRILLIANT to continue her sail-training mission under the flag of Mystic Seaport Museum, uninterrupted.
BRILLIANT is an analog boat in a digital world. Students plot courses on paper charts. They raise the anchor with a hand-operated windlass. They haul sails by hand. Thinking of her crews and the education she provides, I’m reminded of a quote by Capt. Bob Bartlett, the Arctic explorer who was skipper of the schooner ERNESTINA MORRISSEY (then EFFIE M. MORRISSEY). He said it is “good tonic for folks…getting their hands dirty, their muscles hard and their minds cleaned out with the honest experience of the sea and far places.” With phones keeping track of daily schedules and computers offering to write our articles for us, I’d venture that that philosophy—that observation of the elixir of sailing and, by extension, the mission of the schooner BRILLIANT—is more relevant today than ever. As the season winds down here in coastal Maine, I can’t wait to get back on the water next season. I might just leave the phone at home.
Editor of WoodenBoat Magazine